WARNING: This article discusses violent acts against children and attempts of suicide.
The testimony in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, a mother charged with the strangulation of her three children, concluded on Wednesday. This case has sparked significant attention regarding mental health issues following childbirth.
Closing statements are anticipated to commence on Thursday, leading to jury deliberations.
Clancy, aged 36, has entered a plea of not guilty due to a claimed lack of criminal responsibility, with her defense arguing that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the tragic events involving her five-year-old daughter Cora, three-year-old son Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan Clancy, which occurred at their home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023.
This uncommon mental disorder is associated with the pressures, lack of sleep, and hormonal fluctuations that accompany childbirth.
FBI forensic psychiatrist provides testimony
Prosecutors assert that Clancy premeditated the killings and recognized that her actions were immoral.
Clancy did not take the stand during the trial, which has now entered its fifth week. The defense presented ten witnesses, including friends and family members of Clancy, while the prosecution called over 70 witnesses, including her former husband.
As a rebuttal witness for the prosecution, a forensic psychiatrist from the University of Virginia, who also serves as a senior psychiatrist for the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit, stated on Wednesday that he did not accept Clancy’s assertion that a voice commanded her to kill her children.
Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague posed a series of questions to Dr. Gregory Saathoff regarding Clancy’s claims: Did the voice instruct her on where to kill the children? How to do it? What tools to use? In what sequence? Saathoff replied negatively each time.
“She managed to carry out all these actions without any guidance or plan, which is surprising,” he remarked.

Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Gregory Saathoff was one of the last witnesses to testify in the trial. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger/The Associated Press)
The three children were found strangled with exercise bands in the family’s basement before Clancy attempted to take her own life while her husband was out picking up takeout and during a visit to a pharmacy on January 24, 2023. Saathoff indicated that her ability to execute these actions without guidance showed that Clancy “maintained control over the sequence of her actions.”
“The brief period Miss Clancy had alone in the home without her husband was critical for her to carry out the plan, as well as her suicide, quickly and systematically,” he explained.
On Tuesday, Saathoff noted it was peculiar that Clancy claimed the voice ceased once she finished strangling the children, that the voice was continuous rather than sporadic, and that she had never mentioned hearing a voice to her healthcare providers before. Furthermore, she provided inconsistent timelines to other evaluators regarding when she first heard the voice that day, he added.
“The act itself does not cure the voice,” Saathoff remarked about the sudden cessation of the voice. “I have never encountered that before.”
Challenge to psychiatrist’s expertise in postpartum psychosis
Defence lawyer Kevin Reddington initiated his cross-examination of Saathoff on Wednesday by questioning Saathoff’s expertise in postpartum psychosis, suggesting he has a strong affiliation with law enforcement, and probing into his work with prisons, the Justice Department, and the Virginia attorney general’s office.
Saathoff shared that he treated women suffering from postpartum psychosis during his tenure at a state hospital in the 1980s and 1990s, although much of his more recent research has delved into extremist violence, national security, and political radicalization.
Reddington also questioned Saathoff regarding Clancy’s online searches for information about postpartum depression, her multiple visits to maternal and mental health professionals, her disclosures to her mother and ex-husband about her suicidal thoughts and fears of harming her children, as well as her calls to a suicide hotline — all actions Reddington argued demonstrate Clancy’s recognition of her serious issues and her genuine attempts to seek help over time.
Reddington inquired whether Saathoff believed that Clancy chose to kill her children because she “no longer liked the life she thought she wanted” and was making a “selfish choice” to “manipulate her providers, seeking a quick and easy resolution to her feelings of depression and anxiety.”
“I believe that statement you read significantly downplays her experiences,” Saathoff replied.
If you or someone you care about is facing difficulties, here are some resources for assistance:
- Canada’sSuicide Crisis Helpline: Call or text 988.
- Provincial and territorialmental health support.
- Kids Help Phone: 1-800-668-6868. Text 686868. Live chat counselling onthe website.
- This guide from theCentre for Addiction and Mental Healthoutlines how to discuss suicide with someone you are concerned about.

