In a significant overhaul of policing, the system of police and crime commissioners is set to be eliminated. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood declared the Conservative Party’s initiative to introduce PCCs as a “failed experiment,” outlining plans to enhance accountability by empowering local police forces to report to mayors.
Initially established in 2012 by then Home Secretary Theresa May, police and crime commissioners, who are elected officials, hold responsibility for budget allocation within their police jurisdictions and the appointment of chief constables.
During a Commons address, Home Office minister Sarah Jones criticized the PCC model, asserting that it has undermined local police accountability and impacted the recruitment of chief constables negatively. She revealed the decision to abolish Police and Crime Commissioners by 2028, transferring their functions to mayors where feasible. In areas where such a transition is not yet feasible, new policing and crime boards will be instituted to oversee the police force under council leaders’ guidance.
Jones emphasized that the move was not a critique of the PCC model or the commissioners themselves. The Labour Party has long advocated for the abolition of PCCs, with savings redirected to bolster frontline policing efforts. A forthcoming Police Reform white paper will detail the government’s policing agenda.
The Home Office estimates that the removal of PCCs, slated for the end of the next electoral cycle in 2028, will save taxpayers at least £100 million, contributing to the funding of frontline officers. Chairwoman of the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners, Emily Spurrell, expressed concern over the potential creation of an accountability void with the removal of these elected officials, stressing their role in enhancing policing transparency and community engagement.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood affirmed plans to implement new reforms ensuring police accountability to local mayors or councils. The cost savings are earmarked to bolster neighborhood policing efforts nationwide, combating crime and safeguarding communities. Mahmood acknowledged the service of current and former Police and Crime Commissioners, recognizing their dedication to community welfare until the completion of their current terms.