Numerous women’s rights and migrant support groups have accused the Government of promoting a “systematically racist narrative” that shifts blame onto migrants for governmental shortcomings. Over 70 organizations have criticized the Labour Party for reinforcing a hostile environment that ensnares vulnerable women and girls exposed to abuse. They assert that Keir Starmer cannot effectively combat violence against women and girls and modern slavery while maintaining a discriminatory two-tier system based on immigration status.
These groups have raised concerns about the proposals outlined in a contentious immigration white paper unveiled in May, labeling them as “state-sanctioned violence.” In a collective statement addressed to Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, the groups have expressed that the White Paper constructs a deceptive and inherently racist narrative that unfairly targets migrant communities for the systemic failures of the State.
Their statement includes a call to abolish the no recourse to public funds (NRPF) regulations, a visa stipulation that hinders individuals from accessing most benefits and housing allowances. They argue that this restriction prevents high-risk women from receiving essential support, thereby enabling abusers.
Additionally, the groups have urged Mahmood to completely repeal the Tory Illegal Migration Act and the Nationality and Borders Act, which have weakened protections for victims of trafficking. They have demanded the establishment of a “firewall” between support services and immigration enforcement to ensure that victims of abuse feel safe coming forward without the fear of deportation.
Selma Taha, Executive Director of Southall Black Sisters, condemned the Immigration White Paper as a manifestation of the government’s alignment with far-right ideologies in immigration policy. She cautioned that it could further marginalize migrant women and other vulnerable groups, exposing them to destitution, danger, and systemic discrimination.
Andrea Simon, director of the End Violence Against Women Coalition, emphasized the necessity of extending protections irrespective of immigration status to effectively reduce violence against women and girls within a decade. She highlighted the detrimental impact of hostile environment policies on the safety and well-being of women and girls, emphasizing the government’s responsibility to address these issues to ensure a violence-free environment for all.
The groups have advocated for sustained funding for organizations supporting women with NRPF, citing research indicating potential cost savings of £127 million over three years. They have warned against discriminatory enforcement practices, limited access to legal aid, and lack of support, which they argue further marginalize Black and minoritized migrant women.
Gisella Vale, Director of the Latin American Women’s Rights Service, stressed that the government must prioritize the safety of migrant survivors and develop policies aligned with this objective. She criticized policies that attribute violence to immigration, asserting that they not only endanger women seeking safety but also divert attention from the root causes of violence and abuse.
In response, a government spokesperson defended the measures as necessary to regain control over borders after years of unregulated inward migration. They highlighted an ongoing review of the modern slavery system aimed at preventing exploitation and ensuring the protection and dignity of individuals targeted by criminals.
Overall, the groups continue to advocate for inclusive policies that safeguard the rights and well-being of all individuals, irrespective of their immigration status, to combat violence and abuse effectively.