Andy Burnham’s victory in the Makerfield by-election exceeded expectations, nearly doubling Labour’s majority to 9,231. This win showcased the success of a progressive Labour vision over Nigel Farage’s divisive politics, positioning Burnham for a potential run at Downing Street.
Within the Labour Party, supporters of Keir Starmer and Burnham rallied behind their candidates, with the Starmer camp highlighting Labour’s transformation from unelectable to a landslide victory in 2024. However, some MPs criticized the leadership turmoil, urging colleagues to give Starmer more time to enact change.
Despite initial support for Starmer, dissent is growing, with members of his top team now calling for his resignation. Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander privately urged Starmer to plan an exit strategy from No10. Prominent Labour figures, including Harriet Harman and Alan Johnson, acknowledged the inevitability of Starmer’s departure, as internal debates ensue within his circle.
Meanwhile, Burnham’s team aims to avoid a divisive leadership contest, lobbying Labour MPs to gather support for a potential challenge to Starmer’s leadership. Celebrating his victory in Makerfield, Burnham received an enthusiastic reception, with supporters emphasizing the defeat of Reform under his leadership.
While speculation arose about potential leadership challenges, Wes Streeting, a vocal critic of Starmer, paused his intentions following Burnham’s success. Rumors circulated about Streeting potentially striking a deal with Burnham, prompting ally Jess Phillips to express hope for collaboration towards advancing Labour’s agenda and defeating Reform in future elections.