Netflix’s latest popular series, ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story,’ sheds light on the infamous American killer’s dark history. Ed Gein, also known as The Butcher of Plainfield, has been a source of inspiration for various fictional monsters, but this show marks the first time his real-life story is depicted in a true crime setting.
In the series, actor Charlie Hunnam takes on the role of Gein and reenacts key events from the murderer’s life, including his relationship with neighbor Adeline Watkins, portrayed by Suzanna Son. Despite their engagement in the show, their connection proves tumultuous as Adeline eventually leaves for New York before returning to Wisconsin without staying with Gein.
The controversial portrayal suggests that Adeline was aware of Gein’s crimes and even influenced his macabre activities by providing him with disturbing items like photos from Nazi death camps and objects made from human remains. Publicly, the series showcases Adeline speaking out about Gein’s violent tendencies after his capture, culminating in a chilling proposal scene involving a ring taken from a grave.
The depiction has sparked speculation among viewers regarding the authenticity of Adeline and Gein’s relationship. Adeline herself has refuted the idea of a long-term romance, stating that she only met Gein in 1954 when he was already engaging in disturbing behavior.
Showrunner Ian Brennan defended Adeline’s presence in the series, emphasizing the conflicting statements she made about their supposed relationship. While a 1957 interview with the Minneapolis Tribune seemingly supports Adeline’s claim of a decades-long bond with Gein, she later retracted these statements, asserting that they were merely friends.
Gein never publicly acknowledged any romantic involvement with Adeline, leaving the truth behind their relationship shrouded in mystery.